Not as good as it should have been
3
By EugeniaL
It's good, but it's not exceptional. The sound of the guitar is the same on all songs, all the songs have this mellow/slow quality on them, but none really stands out with a strong melody like "Big Coat" & "Whirl" had, or the strong progressive space rock of "Make Things Happen". In other words, this album is not edgy, it's somewhat repetitive, generic. No, it's not a bad album, but it's not edgy, different, memorable, either.
I just refuse to believe that the same people who wrote *masterpieces* like the three older songs I mentioned above can't do the same for a third time. "Satellite Song", "Information", "Across my mind", and "Back in Town" are the better songs on this album, but they can't compete with the older songs mentioned above.
Also, I can't imagine the band playing live with this setlist. It would be a snooze to not have at least 2-3 STRONG rock tracks in the repertoire. Maybe add some more piano too, or other instruments, and be playful with them, because right now, most of the songs have the exact same guitar sound and behavior over time on all tracks.